http://www.thenation.com/doc.mhtml?i=special&s=bivens20011030
a>
And, don't miss "Bush's Uzbek Bargain,"
Dilip Hiro's October 17 Nation web
report, also exclusively available at:
http://www.thenation.com/doc.mhtml?i=special&s=hiro20011017
SEPTEMBER 11 RESOURCES
We've also created a
special page on The Nation
website, where we're collecting all of our September 11
material, including web articles,
links, activist info, a regularly updated section of
media resources, a section on Islam
and remarks on what patriotism is and ought to be. All
available:
http://www.the
nation.com/special/wtc/index.mhtml
11/1/01
6:58:26 PM
Gradual Changes Can Make Ecosystems Vulnerable
By
David Suzuki
A well-known
children's game involves removing wooden blocks from a
block tower one at a time and then
placing each removed piece carefully on top of the
structure. Remarkably, the tower can
often stay standing for quite some time until a key
block is removed and the whole
structure topples into a heap. Thus, the tower changes
catastrophically from one stable
state standing to another
collapsed.
Now, research is showing
that a similar situation can occur in ecosystems. A
recent article in the journal Nature,
for example, presents evidence that various ecosystems
can exist in more than one stable
state and can switch from one to another, but only after
going through a period of
catastrophic change.
The term "stable" is
actually a bit of a misnomer,
because ecosystems are naturally undergoing constant
change, as all things do. But within
certain limits, the ecosystems are able to maintain a
general state of equilibrium. Only
when their limits are surpassed does the state shift.
One of the best examples has
occurred in lakes. In one stable state, a shallow lake
may consist of clear water with
lush vegetation growing on the lake bottom. But over
time, fertilizer run-off from
agriculture, for example, may load the lake with excess
nutrients. These nutrients can
build up and the lake can remain clear for years before
a critical threshold is reached
and the lake suddenly changes from clear to murky. Algae
then grow on the surface, and
bottom-dwelling plants, deprived of light and oxygen,
die off, making the water even more
turbid and inhospitable to fish and other life.
The
authors of the Nature article, an
international group of ecologists, point out that
returning the lake to its clear state is
not simply a matter of reducing nutrient levels to those
before the shift. Once the fish,
plants, and other organisms who were essential to
maintaining the clarity of the lake were
gone, clear water would not return until nutrient levels
are far lower than they were when
the collapse occurred. That makes restoring the
ecosystem even more difficult.
This
type of ecosystem shift has also been documented in
coral reefs. In the Caribbean, for
example, many reefs have become colonized by fleshy
microalgae. The algae had previously
been kept in check by herbivorous fish and sea urchins,
but nutrient run-off and
overfishing caused fish stocks to plummet. Then, when a
pathogen devastated the sea urchin
population, a shift occurred and the algae rapidly
colonized the reef.
Crucial to
these examples is the point that changes between stable
states did not occur gradually or
smoothly. Instead, the changes were unannounced, and
early warning signals of impending
catastrophic change were unnoticed or difficult to
detect. The authors conclude,
"gradual change in environmental conditions, such
as human-induced eutrophication
(oxygen depletion) and global warming, may have little
apparent effect on the state of
these systems but still alter the 'stability domain' or
resilience of the current state
and, hence, the likelihood that a shift to an
alternative state will occur in response to
natural or human-induced fluctuations."
What
this means is that an ecosystem like
a forest or a lake may continue to appear normal, even
though pollution or the loss of
species is actually weakening it. Then suddenly that
apparent stability can no longer be
maintained and a collapse occurs. Unfortunately, we
can't predict when and how that will
happen, and once it does, restoring the original state
may be impossible or take decades
or even centuries. It makes far more ecological and
economic sense to protect what we've
got rather than attempting to put blocks in place after
a collapse.
Source: http://www.enn.com/news/enn-
stories/2001/11/11012001/s_45424.asp
11/1/01
6:55:04 PM
FAIR
Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting
Media analysis, critiques and news
reports
ACTION ALERT: CNN Says Focus on Civilian
Casualties Would Be
"Perverse"
According to the Washington
Post (10/31/01), CNN Chair Walter
Isaacson "has ordered his staff to balance images
of civilian devastation in Afghan
cities with reminders that the Taliban harbors murderous
terrorists, saying it 'seems
perverse to focus too much on the casualties or hardship
in Afghanistan.'"
Post
media reporter Howard Kurtz quotes a memo from Isaacson
to CNN's international
correspondents: "As we get good reports from
Taliban-controlled Afghanistan, we must
redouble our efforts to make sure we do not seem to be
simply reporting from their vantage
or perspective. We must talk about how the Taliban are
using civilian shields and how the
Taliban have harbored the terrorists responsible for
killing close to 5,000 innocent
people."
The memo went on to admonish reporters
covering civilian deaths not to
"forget it is that country's leaders who are
responsible for the situation
Afghanistan is now in," suggesting that journalists
should lay responsibility for
civilian casualties at the Taliban's door, not the U.S.
military's.
Kurtz also quotes
a follow-up memo from Rick Davis, CNN's head of
standards and practices, that suggested
sample language for news anchors:
" 'We must
keep in mind, after seeing reports
like this from Taliban-controlled areas, that these U.S.
military actions are in response
to a terrorist attack that killed close to 5,000
innocent people in the U.S.' or, 'We must
keep in mind, after seeing reports like this, that the
Taliban regime in Afghanistan
continues to harbor terrorists who have praised the
September 11 attacks that killed close
to 5,000 innocent people in the U.S.,' or 'The Pentagon
has repeatedly stressed that it is
trying to minimize civilian casualties in Afghanistan,
even as the Taliban regime
continues to harbor terrorists who are connected to the
September 11 attacks that claimed
thousands of innocent lives in the U.S.' "
Davis stated that "even though it
may start sounding rote, it is important that we make
this point each time."
The
New York Times reported (11/1/01) that these policies
are already being implemented at
CNN, with other networks following a similar, though
perhaps not as formalized, strategy.
"In the United States," the Times noted,
"television images of Afghan
bombing victims are fleeting, cushioned between anchors
or American officials explaining
that such sights are only one side of the story."
In other countries, however,
"images of wounded Afghan children curled in
hospital beds or women rocking in
despair over a baby's corpse" are "more
frequent and lingering."
When
CNN correspondent Nic Robertson reported yesterday from
the site of a bombed medical
facility in Kandahar, the Times reported, U.S. anchors
"added disclaimers aimed at
reassuring American viewers that the network was not
siding with the enemy." CNN
International, however, did not add any such
disclaimers.
During its U.S broadcasts,
CNN "quickly switched to the rubble of the World
Trade Center" after showing
images of the damage in Kandahar, and the anchor
"reminded viewers of the deaths of
as many as 5,000 people whose 'biggest crime was going
to work and getting there on
time.'"
If anything in this story is
"perverse," it's that one of the
world's most powerful news outlets has instructed its
journalists not to report Afghan
civilian casualties without attempting to justify those
deaths. "I want to make sure
we're not used as a propaganda platform," Isaacson
told the Washington Post. But his
memo essentially mandates that pro-U.S. propaganda be
included in the news.
ACTION:
Please tell CNN to factually report the consequences of
the U.S. war in Afghanistan
without editorializing. Including a justification for
the bombing with every mention of
civilian casualties risks turning CNN from a news outlet
into a propaganda service.
CONTACT:
CNN, Walter Isaacson, Chairman and CEO
Phone: (404) 827-1500
Fax:
(404) 827-1784
mailto:community@cnn.com
As
always, please remember that your comments are taken
more seriously if you maintain a
polite tone.
Please cc fair@fair.org with your
correspondence.
For further
details, see Howard Kurtz's full Washington Post story:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A14435-
2001Oct30.html
11/1/01
6:51:48 PM
Environmental news from GRIST MAGAZINE
<http:
//www.gristmagazine.com/grist/default.asp?source=top>
OUR SNICKER
The Bush administration tucked its
tail between its legs and decided
yesterday to toughen the limit for arsenic in drinking
water from 50 parts per billion to
the 10 ppb. The stricter standard was originally
approved by the Clinton administration,
but then rejected by current U.S. EPA Administrator
Christie Whitman, who questioned the
science behind it and said the cost would be prohibitive
for small communities.
Environmentalists denounced her decision, and held it up
as a shining example of the Bush
administration's hostility toward the environment.
Whitman changed her tune following a
public comment period and a report by the National
Academy of Sciences that indicated that
the risks of developing cancer and other health problems
from arsenic-contaminated water
-- even at 10 ppb -- are much greater than previously
thought.
straight to the source:
Washington Post, Edward Walsh, 01 Nov 2001 <http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A20926-
2001Oct31.html>
THE PERSISTENCE OF MERCURY
Anyone who's ever
broken an old-style thermometer
knows it's tough to clean up mercury, but the state of
Washington is undeterred. The
state's Ecology Department has created the nation's only
program to battle persistent
bioaccumulative toxins, or PBTs, and mercury will be the
first target. Found in substances
ranging from eye makeup to industrial waste to
contaminated seafood, mercury can cause
neurological problems and birth defects. Nearly 3,700
pounds of mercury from industrial
sites are known to have contaminated air, land, and
water in Washington last year, and
untold additional pounds went unreported.
straight
to the source: Seattle
Post-Intelligencer, Lisa Stiffler, 30 Oct 2001 <http://seattlep-
i.nwsource.com/local/44651_mercury30.shtml>
CLIMATE CONTRAIL
Of the many unprecedented
events of Sept. 11, one of them --
the near-absence of airplanes in the skies that day and
the next -- has given scientists
important clues for studying the impact of aviation on
climate change. Normally, the sky
above 25,000 feet is full of contrails, cloud-like
phenomena that form when ice crystals
bond to jet fumes. Climatologists have long suspected
that contrails contribute to global
warming, but with constant air traffic, there was no way
to compare the sky with and
without airplanes. Now scientists are optimistic that
data from Sept. 11 and 12 will help
refine climate change computer modeling. Meanwhile for
an update on the climate
negotiation scene, as the latest round of international
talks begins this week in Morocco,
visit the Grist Magazine website.
straight to the
source: New York Times, Andrew C.
Revkin, 30 Oct 2001 <htt
p://www.nytimes.com/2001/10/30/science/earth/30CONT.html>
BUTTERFLIES IN THEIR STOMACHS
Seventy-five
percent of butterfly species in the
United Kingdom are in decline, according to a study
published this week in the journal
Nature. Some experts had expected butterflies to be
doing well as a result of global
warming, because milder weather was expected to increase
the ranges of many species. But
temperature increases in the U.K. haven't been enough to
compensate for habitat loss. The
study, which was coordinated by Butterfly Conservation
and three British universities,
attributed the diminishing number of butterflies to the
destruction of meadows, woodlands,
and moors, and warned that without significant
intervention many species would become rare
or extinct.
straight to the source: BBC News, Helen
Briggs, 31 Oct 2001 <http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/sci/tech/newsid_1630000/1630193
.stm>
11/1/01
6:34:15 PM
Public Citizen Urges NRC, Congress to Take Hint From
FAA
Flight Ban Underscores
Dangers of Nuclear Power Plants
WASHINGTON, D.C. -
Flight restrictions around nuclear
power plants imposed this week by the federal government
underscore how dangerous the
plants are and serve as further proof that nuclear power
plants should not be relicensed
and new plants should not be built, Public Citizen said
today.
On Tuesday, the Federal
Aviation Administration (FAA) prohibited all general
aviation flights within 10 miles of,
and lower than 18,000 feet above, the nation's
commercial nuclear power plants and other
nuclear facilities, for reasons of national security.
Such concern is not unwarranted; a
disciple of Osama bin Laden being held in Afghanistan by
the Northern Alliance was quoted
in The Washington Post this week as saying that the
terrorists who struck America on Sept.
11 should have targeted a nuclear plant.
But while
the FAA apparently recognizes the
threat posed by nuclear plants, others in government are
continuing efforts to expand and
subsidize the nuclear industry. The Nuclear Regulatory
Commission (NRC) is still working
toward relicensing nuclear plants, and congressional
lawmakers are continuing to push a
measure that would require taxpayers pay the majority of
the costs in the event of a
nuclear accident.
"Since Sept. 11, the public
has been seeking assurances that
nuclear power plants will not be the next, and
incredibly devastating, targets of
terrorist attacks," said Wenonah Hauter, director
of Public Citizen's Critical Mass
Energy and Environment Program. "Yet astonishingly,
even in the midst of a seemingly
interminable series of heightened alerts, federal
policymakers are acting to enrich the
target environment for terrorists by taking steps to
build new nuclear plants and extend
the lives of old ones."
Nuclear power plants
were originally licensed to operate
for 40 years. Relicensing allows them to operate for
another 20. In the weeks since Sept.
11, the NRC has forged ahead with the process of
renewing licenses for reactors at several
nuclear power plants. (The plants are Edwin E. Hatch,
located northwest of Savannah, Ga.;
Turkey Point, located northeast of Miami, Fla.; Surry,
located near Williamsburg, Va.;
North Anna, located northwest of Richmond, Va.; Catawba,
in South Carolina, just south of
Charlotte, N.C.; McGuire, located west of Charlotte,
N.C.; and Peach Bottom, located west
of Philadelphia.) Ultimately, perhaps as many as two-
thirds of the nation's 103 operating
reactors could be granted extensions through the NRC's
pro forma relicensing procedure.
"It's often said that September 11 changed
everything," Hauter said. "But
not for the NRC, which is continuing business as usual.
For the agency to just keep moving
along on these license renewal applications is
irresponsible and bizarre."
Meanwhile, on Wednesday, the House Energy and Commerce
Committee approved H.R. 2983, which
reauthorizes the Price-Anderson Act. That act provides
government-backed indemnification
for the nuclear power industry in the event of any
nuclear power accident. This will
ensure that most of the cost of a nuclear plant accident
would be paid for by taxpayers,
not the nuclear power industry.
The bill's
supporters say it is crucial for the
construction of new nuclear power plants - evidence that
the government wants to shield
the industry from competitive market forces and
effectively pave the way for the
construction of new plants.
"The construction
of new nuclear power plants is out
of step with public sentiment, particularly now,"
Hauter said. "It's also
unnecessary and incomprehensible. Really, what are these
people thinking?"
Public
Citizen is a nonprofit consumer advocacy organization
based in Washington, D.C.
For
more information, please visit http:www.citizen.org
11/1/01
6:22:37 PM
ENVIRONMENT NEWS SERVICE
http://ens-news.com
ANTHRAX CLAIMS A FOURTH LIFE
WASHINGTON, DC, October
31, 2001 (ENS) - A fourth person
has died of inhalation anthrax, and in this puzzling new
case, there seems to be no link
to anthrax contaminated post offices or mailrooms.
Authorities fear the victim, a 61 year
old woman who worked at a New York City hospital, could
point to previously unknown
targets of anthrax attacks.
For full text and
graphics visit:
http://ens-news.com/ens/oct2001/2001L-10-31-07.html
NEW ZEALAND TO RESUME TRANSGENIC CROP TRIALS
By Bob Burton
WELLINGTON, New
Zealand, October 31, 2001 (ENS) - The New Zealand Labor
Government has decided to allow
the resumption of field trials of genetically modified
organisms. The move, announced by
Prime Minister Helen Clark on Tuesday, has been welcomed
by biotech lobby groups and
rejected by environmental and indigenous Maori groups.
For full text and graphics
visit:
http://ens-
news.com/ens/oct2001/2001L-10-31-01.html
ENVIRONMENT STILL OFF WORLD TRADE TALKS AGENDA
BRUSSELS, Belgium, October 31,
2001 (ENS) - The odds of a new round of world trade
negotiations including substantive
talks on environmental issues have lengthened following
the emergence of a new draft text
for ministerial agreement at the Doha summit, due to
start on November 9. Despite strong
pressure from the European Union, the draft proposes no
new environmental negotiations.
For full text and graphics visit:
http://ens-
news.com/ens/oct2001/2001L-10-31-04.html
BACKYARD BAT HOUSES PROMOTE PEST CONTROL
GAINESVILLE, Florida, October 31,
2001 (ENS) - If you see more bats this Halloween, it may
be because homeowners are
installing backyard bat houses to encourage the flying
mammals to hang around and provide
natural pest control, says a University of Florida (UF)
expert.
For full text and
graphics visit:
http://ens-
news.com/ens/oct2001/2001L-10-31-06.html
ENVIRONMENT NEWS SERVICE AMERISCAN: OCTOBER 31,
2001
Nature Conservancy
Campaign Protects Colorado Wildlands
Coalition:
Manatee Recovery Plan Needs More Work
Agriculture Department Appoints Natural Resources
Secretary
New York Grant Supports
New Energy Efficiency Standards
Alaska Tightens
Security on Hazmat Shipments
Long
Island Utility Installs Fuel Cells
Union Builds
Green Headquarters
Arizona Hosts
Colorado Plateau Conference
Furniture Company Seeks
Exemption to Fill Wetlands
Energy Department Celebrates Weatherization Day
For
full text and graphics visit:
http://ens-
news.com/ens/oct2001/2001L-10-31-09.html
11/1/01
6:17:41 PM
Bin Laden's Family Cutting Ties With Carlyle Group
Investment Firm
by Marcy Gordon,
The Associated Press
WASHINGTON (AP) - Osama bin
Laden's family in Saudi Arabia is
cutting its financial ties with the Carlyle Group, a
politically connected U.S. private
investment firm, a source familiar with the relationship
said Friday.
The break was a
mutual decision, said the source, who spoke on condition
of anonymity.
The bin Laden
family decided to sell its investment worth $2.02
million back to the firm mainly because
its stake in a Carlyle fund that invests in buyouts of
military and aerospace companies,
the source said, confirming a report in Friday's
editions of The New York Times.
There
had been criticism in Saudi Arabia after the Sept. 11
terror attacks that the family,
which disowned exiled Islamic militant Osama bin Laden
years ago, might profit from
increased military spending in the U.S. war against
terrorism.
The family, whose
construction company is one of the largest in the Middle
East, also has invested with a
number of other investment funds and financial
institutions around the world, reportedly
including U.S. financial services giant Citigroup,
Deutsche Bank of Germany and the Dutch
bank ABN Amro.
Carlyle has some $14 billion in
assets under management. Its chairman
is Frank Carlucci, a former U.S. defense secretary.
Former President George Bush, former
secretary of state James Baker and Arthur Levitt, who
had been chairman of the Securities
and Exchange Commission through most of the Clinton
administration, are senior advisers to
the firm.
Source: http://www.truthout.com/11.0
1E.htm
11/1/01
6:12:12 PM
MediaChannel.org
DAILY MEDIA NEWS
Breaking
news stories about the international
media, from mainstream and alternative sources.
http://www.mediachannel
.org/news/today/
Global conflict coverage exclusively from
Globalvision News Network.
http://www.gvnewsne
t.com/html/USUnderAttack
OCTOBER 31, 2001 *New Features*
SHOULD WE
TRASH MEDIA OWNERSHIP RULES? The
official comment period for revising media ownership
rules continues. MediaChannel
affiliates explain what's at stake and offer easy ways
to make your voice heard.
http://www.mediac
hannel.org/atissue/ownership
ANYWHERE, ANYTIME ACCESS
John Vince and Robert
McChesney on the problems and
promise of "digital convergence," where
computer and communication technologies
meet. (From UNESCO)
http://www.med
iachannel.org/front.shtml#converge
MEDIA READER
The best media about the media.
MediaChannel's international,
biweekly, multimedia magazine * Nickelodeon Demolishes
Moldova's Kids * Testing Drug Ads *
Covering The Energy Crisis And much, much more... Plus:
Streaming audio and video
http://www.mediach
annel.org/news/mediareader
GLOBAL MEDIA LANDSCAPE: BELARUS
Last month's
election bodes ill for the
independent press of Belarus, especially because the
United States backed the losing
candidate.
http://w
ww.mediachannel.org/news/reports/Belarus.shtml
MEDIACULTURE
A collaboration between
MediaChannel and Alternet exploring the
currents, crises and cultures of American media.
Recently featured: * Funders Boycott
Public Radio * AOL Censors Springsteen Lyrics * Lynn
"Culture Warrior" Cheney
And much, much more...
http://www
.mediachannel.org/front.shtml#mediaculture
11/1/01
6:05:57 PM
AlterNet Headlines
http://www.alternet.org
OPERATION ENDURING AVARICE
Arianna Huffington,
AlterNet
The so-called economic
stimulus package that passed the House last week will
dole out untold billions to major
corporations and almost nothing to folks who have lost
their jobs since 9/11.
http://www.alt
ernet.org/story.html?StoryID=11839
$1.4 BILLION FOR IBM + $1 BILLION FOR FORD = WAR
PROFITEERING IBM wants a $1.4
billion tax rebate. Ford wants $1 billion. Countless
other corporations are looking for
huge handouts. If the Senate approves the phony
"economic stimulus" package, Big
Business could pocket over $70 billion. Learn more and
take action to stop the bill at:
http://www.ourfuture.org
AFTER THE TALIBAN, CAN
A COALITION GOVERNMENT SURVIVE?
Michael Kamber,
Village Voice
Which of the
factions will take power: the exiled king Zahir Shah,
the Northern Alliance or a former
mujahedeen warlord? Or will the Taliban hold on? A
report from Central Asia.
http://www.alt
ernet.org/story.html?StoryID=11834
RELIGIOUS RIGHT ON THE ROPES
Bill Berkowitz,
AlterNet
The Religious Right has
taken a beating since Sept. 11, suffering ridicule for
its leaders' remarks and
comparisons to fundamental Islam. A survey of the
Right's folly since the attacks.
http://www.alt
ernet.org/story.html?StoryID=11840
IS QUESTIONING WAR NAïVE?
Tim Wise, AlterNet
When warhawks call those of us
who question war "naïve," it reminds me of
something my Grandma once said:
"You can call your ass a turkey, but that doesn't
make it Thanksgiving."
http://www.alt
ernet.org/story.html?StoryID=11833
CONFESSIONS OF A CALL GIRL'S FRIEND
Dara
Colwell, Metro Silicon Valley
'Toni'
made no secret of her occupation when I interviewed as a
roommate, but even though she
never brought her tricks home, there are some parts of
any job that can't be left behind.
http://www.alt
ernet.org/story.html?StoryID=11836
SMACKED OUT
Mara Shalhoup, Creative Loafing
Atlanta
Believers say a
little-known drug called ibogaine eases heroin cravings
and withdrawal, but it's never
gained popularity with pharmaceutical